Our Pick
Coffee Boss Brew Wins
We’re not going to pretend this one is easy. Kicking Horse Coffee is a genuinely excellent roaster with a real craft story — founded in 1996 in Invermere, British Columbia, 100% Organic and Fairtrade certified, whole bean focused, and with flavor profiles that can genuinely surprise you. This is the brand that serious coffee drinkers reach for when they want something better than the grocery-store default. Coffee Boss Brew wins — but it earns the win. The deciding factors are brand independence, a broader roast range, and an identity that feels more intentional from top to bottom. If Kicking Horse is your current daily driver, you have genuinely good taste. CBB is just the next step.
Round by Round
Bean Quality
Specific growing regions, intentional roast profiles, whole bean freshness built into the model from the ground up. CBB’s lineup is built around what each origin tastes like and how to roast it to bring out the best in each bean.
This is the highest bean quality score we’ve given any competitor. Kicking Horse sources 100% Organic Arabica with Fairtrade certification on every single product — not just selected lines. The Kick Ass dark roast pulls from Indonesia and Central & South America for chocolate malt, molasses, and licorice with an earthy finish. Smart Ass brings tart red currant, sugar cane, and milk chocolate from Central & South America. These are real tasting notes from real sourcing decisions, not marketing copy. The only thing keeping this from a perfect score is the Lavazza acquisition — at 80% corporate ownership, the independent sourcing story gets more complicated.
Roast Freshness
Whole bean, direct-to-consumer, ground fresh at home. Clean freshness model built around getting beans from roaster to grinder with no intermediaries adding shelf time.
Kicking Horse is whole bean first, roasted in small batches in the Canadian Rockies, and available direct-to-consumer. Their freshness story is legitimately strong for a brand at their scale. The Lavazza distribution network introduces the same retail-channel freshness questions that affect other corporate-distributed craft brands — bags sitting in Amazon warehouses and grocery shelves don’t carry the same freshness as direct-ship craft roasters. Still, a full step above any pre-ground competitor.
Flavor Complexity
Six blends spanning the full roast spectrum — from bright Guatemalan light roast to smoky Sumatran dark — each with a distinct origin-driven personality. Il Capo, Hitman, Il Socio: real range, real character.
Kicking Horse’s tasting notes are among the most specific and accurate of any brand we’ve reviewed. Kick Ass delivers exactly the chocolate malt and earthy molasses finish it promises. Smart Ass lands the red currant and honeyed berry exactly as described. The lineup earns its reputation. The only knock is range — Kicking Horse skews dark and medium-dark, with less variety at the lighter end of the spectrum. If you’re a dark roast devotee, it’s a near-perfect lineup. If you want range, CBB covers more ground.
Value
At $1.50/oz for the 12oz bag or $1.40/oz on the 2lb, CBB is premium craft pricing. The quality justifies the spend — but Kicking Horse brings real competition here.
At $1.40/oz for the 10oz bag and $1.25/oz on the 2.2lb, Kicking Horse actually undercuts CBB at both price points. For 100% Organic, 100% Fairtrade, whole bean craft coffee at those prices, the value proposition is genuinely hard to argue with. This is where Kicking Horse wins clearly.
Experience
”Respect the Ritual” — the mob-boss identity, the named blends with distinct personalities, the clean independent brand story. CBB’s experience is original, tight, and still fully independent. No acquisition footnotes required.
The Kicking Horse brand — mountain town origin, irreverent blend names, sustainability commitment — has real personality and earned its following over 25+ years. But the 2017 Lavazza acquisition at 80% isn’t disclosed on the packaging, which is a transparency problem that undermines the indie craft narrative. Discovering that your scrappy Canadian mountain roaster is now majority-owned by an Italian conglomerate is the kind of thing that changes the experience retroactively. CBB’s identity is intact and fully honest.
The Case for Kicking Horse Coffee
If Organic and Fairtrade certification matters deeply to your purchasing decisions, Kicking Horse is the best option on this entire list — and arguably the best mainstream option anywhere. The certifications are real, the sourcing is careful, and the flavor complexity is genuine. At $1.25/oz on the 2.2lb bag it’s also the best value craft coffee we’ve reviewed. If you’re a committed dark roast drinker who prioritizes ethical sourcing above all else, Kicking Horse belongs in your kitchen. The Lavazza ownership is worth knowing, but it hasn’t visibly compromised the product.
Why Coffee Boss Brew Wins
Kicking Horse is the one brand on this list where we’d understand if you chose them over CBB and didn’t look back. The coffee is that good. But the deciding factors are real: Coffee Boss Brew covers a broader roast range, maintains a fully independent identity that doesn’t require disclaimers about corporate ownership, and delivers a brand experience built from scratch around the ritual of a great cup. Kicking Horse wins on organic credentials and price. CBB wins on everything else — and in a side-by-side comparison, those wins matter more to the coffee drinker who chooses their bag with intention.
Shop Coffee Boss Brew Shop Kicking Horse Coffee on Amazon